Honourable and personal residential letting experts

30Sep

The biggest change after Section 21 isn’t Eviction – it’s who gets the keys

When Section 21 disappeared on 1 May 2026, most of the conversation focused on how landlords would regain possession of their properties. But I believe one of the biggest consequences will happen much earlier: before a tenancy has even begun.

If choosing the wrong resident now takes longer and costs considerably more to resolve, landlords will naturally become more careful about whom they accept.

That makes accurate, professional referencing more important than ever. It may also make life harder for good applicants whose circumstances do not fit neatly into a standard referencing box.

For Cambridgeshire landlords, the question is no longer simply: “Can this applicant afford the rent today?”

It is: “Have I gathered enough reliable evidence to be confident that this tenancy is sustainable?”

That is a much more complicated question.

protection

More protection at the end means more scrutiny at the beginning

Section 21 was abolished in England on 1 May 2026 under the Renters’ Rights Act. Landlords must now rely on one of the prescribed possession grounds when they need to recover their property. This does not mean that a landlord can never regain possession. Grounds include selling, moving into the property, rent arrears, antisocial behaviour, and breaches of the tenancy.

However, the process is now more evidence-led.

A landlord intending to sell or move back into a property will usually need to use the appropriate ground, satisfy its requirements and give four months’ notice. If the landlord seeks possession because of rent arrears or another breach, they must be able to prove the relevant ground.

The Government’s own guidance confirms that Section 21 can no longer be used for new or existing tenancies and that landlords must use a legally valid ground for possession. This inevitably changes the calculation at the beginning of a tenancy.

A poor decision can expose a landlord to unpaid rent, legal costs, property damage and a lengthy possession process. Even when a landlord ultimately succeeds, recovering the money owed may be another matter entirely.

It is therefore understandable that Cambridgeshire landlords want greater certainty before handing over the keys, but greater care must not become unfair or automatic exclusion.

What robust referencing should really look like

Referencing should not be a tick-box exercise, and it certainly should not consist of simply accepting a few payslips and a previous landlord’s email.

At Maxine Lester, we review around 50 references each month. That volume matters because it allows us to see changing patterns, inconsistencies and attempted fraud that an individual landlord (who may reference only one new resident every few years) might rarely encounter.

At present, we disregard approximately 15% of applications because something does not appear to be right.

That does not mean we reject everyone with complicated circumstances; it means we investigate the evidence and, where the information cannot be satisfactorily verified, we do not ignore the warning signs.

A robust referencing process should consider several areas.

Identity and Right to Rent

A landlord or letting agent must establish that the applicant is who they say they are and complete the legally required Right to Rent checks.

Documents must be checked carefully. Fraudulent identity documents, altered bank statements and invented employment references are becoming increasingly sophisticated. A document looking professional is not proof that it is genuine.

Income and affordability

It is reasonable to assess whether the proposed rent is affordable, but a headline salary figure rarely tells the whole story.

For a PAYE employee, this may involve confirming employment, income and the stability of their role. For somebody who is self-employed, the evidence may include accounts, tax calculations, tax-year overviews and bank information.

We recently investigated an application where the stated income came from a business, but the applicant could not provide the expected tax evidence. That was a clear warning sign.

The lesson was not that self-employed residents are automatically risky. The lesson was that declared income must be independently verifiable.

Credit history

A credit check may reveal County Court Judgments, insolvency or other financial difficulties. However, the information still needs to be understood in context.

When did the problem arise? Has it been settled? Was it an isolated incident or part of a continuing pattern? Does the applicant’s current financial position support the proposed rent?

An unexplained adverse entry should not be ignored, but neither should every applicant with an imperfect history automatically be treated as unsuitable.

Open banking and financial evidence

Bank statements can be altered. This is one reason we use open-banking information where appropriate rather than relying exclusively on documents supplied by the applicant.

The objective is not to intrude unnecessarily into someone’s finances; it is to verify that the income and financial commitments presented in the application reflect reality.

Previous tenancy history

A previous landlord or agent can provide useful information about payment history and how the tenancy was conducted.

However, references must also be authenticated. A mobile number and a friendly email are not necessarily evidence that the person giving the reference is genuinely the applicant’s landlord. This is where proper investigation makes a difference.

Guarantors and additional security

A guarantor can strengthen an application, but only if they are properly referenced and understand the commitment being made.

A guarantor who cannot afford the potential liability offers little practical protection. The guarantee itself must also be correctly drafted and executed.

Good applicants do not always fit a computer-generated score

The danger of stricter referencing is that perfectly responsible applicants can be filtered out because their income is unusual rather than unreliable.

Self-employed people, contractors, people receiving benefits and those who have recently changed jobs may not fit a standard automated model. That does not necessarily make them unsuitable residents.
The answer is not to reduce the quality of referencing. It is to improve the quality of the assessment.

A good process should consider the complete evidence, ask sensible follow-up questions and apply consistent criteria. It should distinguish between an applicant whose situation requires more investigation and one whose evidence simply does not withstand scrutiny.

There are also important legal limits. Since 1 May 2026, it has been unlawful to disadvantage prospective residents because they receive benefits or have children. That includes preventing viewings, withholding information or refusing a tenancy for that reason.

Landlords can still assess whether a tenancy is affordable. They cannot use a blanket “no benefits” or “no children” policy. That distinction is extremely important.

Referencing is risk management – not a guarantee

Even the most thorough referencing cannot predict everything that may happen over a tenancy lasting several years.

Employment can end. Relationships can break down. Businesses can fail, and health can change. Referencing provides evidence of the applicant’s position at a particular point; it cannot guarantee the future.

What it can do is identify inconsistencies, expose fraud and help a landlord make a fair, informed and defensible decision. It also creates an audit trail showing what information was considered and that the same criteria were applied consistently.

That is particularly valuable under the new possession system. For example, if false information was provided to obtain the tenancy, there is a specific possession ground—but the landlord must have the evidence to support it.

landlord handing keys to tenant

The wrong time to discover a problem is after the keys are handed over

The abolition of Section 21 has not removed risk from the private rented sector. It has moved more of that risk to the beginning of the relationship.

For landlords across Cambridge, St Ives, Huntingdon, Ely and the surrounding Cambridgeshire villages, referencing is no longer a routine administrative step – it is one of the most important risk-management decisions you will make.

My advice is straightforward:

Do not rush because you are worried about a void. Do not rely entirely on an automated pass or fail. And don’t ignore something that doesn’t feel right just because you want the tenancy to begin.

A few extra days spent verifying an application can be far less expensive than months spent resolving a tenancy that should never have been agreed.

At Maxine Lester Lettings & Property Management, we combine professional referencing with human investigation and local knowledge. If you are a Cambridgeshire landlord who wants greater certainty before accepting a new resident, speak to us before you hand over the keys.

Enjoyed reading this?

If you enjoy reading these weekly updates, why not leave us a review on Google and help other landlords find the right information and support they need.

Why not follow us on your favourite social media channel?